The Interested Bystander’s Oscar Predictions: October 2024

Dìdi (c) A24 / Saturday Night (c) Sony Pictures

Here we are in October, and I feel like I’m already late in providing reminder nominees for the Oscars before the nominees solidifies with critic awards. Already the Gotham Award nominees have thrown things askew, as they nominated Yura Borisov as the sympathetic henchman in Anora (my favorite as well) for Supporting Actor while I still think that the more scene stealing Karren Karagulian has the better chance. My two reminders are in Supporting categories with Joan Chen as the caring mother in Dìdi (the only Asian actor with a chance to make the list this year) and Lamorne Morris, who seems to be in his own movie as Garrett Morris in Saturday Night. Both stand out in the noise of their respective movies and should be seriously considered. 

Here is how I think the Oscar nominations would shake out if given out now. 

Enjoy. 

Theater Review: “Romeo + Juliet: The Jellicle Ball” Sashays Its Way to Broadway; Grover’s Corners Retain Its Power in Latest “Our Town” and “The Big Gay Jamboree” is a Big Gay Romp Off-Broadway

Romeo + Juliet (c) Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman

Broadway: Romeo + Juliet 
At Circle in the Square Theatre 

A big welcome to what I’m dubbing Romeo + Juliet: The Jellicle Ball to Broadway. Unlike many revivals that highlight the playwright’s name (Arthur Miller’s Death of Salesman, Suzan-Lori Parks’s Topdog/Underdog), William Shakespeare seems more like a jumping-off point than the author of this energetic, youthful production by the deconstructionist and busy director Sam Gold. Gold’s adaptation feels like a high school senior’s dissertation of the play that focuses on odd moments (the nurse’s monologue about her child) and totally disregards bigger moments (like the fight with Paris at the end of the play) to fix his thesis. This would be fatal if it wasn’t obvious from the start that this production was less about the text and more of the spirit of two households whose feud trickles down to their children, all of high school age, where animosity and hatred are well-worn jackets. 

Film Reviews: “Memoir of a Snail” Is an Inventive and Heart-wrenching Animated Film for Adults, While “High Tide” and “We Live in Time” Give Their Respective Love Stories Some Gravitas

Memoir of a Snail (c) IFC Films

Review: Memoir of a Snail 
In Cinemas 

If I were to take a stand and declare Adam Elliot’s stop-motion Memoir of a Snail as the best animated film of 2024, then I would have to battle fans of Dreamworks’ The Wild Robot, of which there are many. I concede that Robot does indeed have the better animation, with its dueling glorious nature vistas and a vision of a tech-dominated world, but Snail, painstakingly rendered in a somewhat bleaker animated vision, has the better story. Like Elliot’s remarkable earlier films, the Oscar-winning short Harvie Krumpet and the underrated feature Mary and Max, Snail centers around an imperfect protagonist. Her name is Grace (a wonderful Sarah Snook, channeling the cadence of Hannah Gadsby), an Australian woman who, at the start of the film, mourns the loss of a friend and, as tradition, releases one of her pet snails into the garden while narrating her life up to this point. Her mother died in childbirth and her father is a failed, alcoholic street magician, so her only lifeline is her brother Gilbert (Kodi Smit-McPhee), who would do anything, as when he is asked as a young boy to give blood to save his sister and he says yes, even though he believes he would have to die in order to do so. This kind of charming kids’ logic is pervasive throughout the film, especially when the siblings are separated, and Gilbert goes to live with a religious family and Grace goes to a couple whose extracurricular activities are too delicious to spoil here. Their separate journeys and occasional letters to each other make up the bulk of the film, both full of heartache and strife but always with a hint of (possibly pointless) optimism. Along with Elliot’s inventive animated vision, the film’s biggest assets have to be the quirky but always engaging score by Elena Kats-Chernin and the vocal performance of Snook (Emmy-winner for Succession), which, like the late Philip Seymour Hoffman in Mary, is both heartbreaking and joyful. Other outstanding voice performances include the invaluable Jacki Weaver and a smooth Eric Bana. Elliot also does not shy away from the darker aspects of human existence (Grace’s relationship with snails may be a symptom of a more serious underlying condition), so it is definitely not a children’s animated film. But in the battle between the slick Robot and the scrappy Snail, I believe the snail wins this year’s animated race by a slow, but wide, slimy mile. 

Theater Reviews: Writers Struggle With Integrity in “McNeal” (Novelist), “Safety Not Guaranteed” (Journalist) and “Yellow Face” (Playwright)

Yellow Face (c) Joan Marcus

Broadway: Yellow Face 
At the Todd Haimes Theatre 

Playwright David Henry Hwang has written for different genres from opera (Alice in Wonderland, The Fly) to musicals (Tarzan, Aida), usually adapted from various mediums. For his own personal works, the medium he adapts from his own life. Like his last musical, Soft Power, in Yellow Face, which is having a splashy Broadway revival after premiering Off-Broadway in 2007, the main character is DHH, and even if the story may veer into the fictional, it always seems to be inspired by real events in Hwang’s life. There are two major events in Yellow Face, and if you look at the playwright’s Wikipedia page, they did happen: Hwang (played with quizzical fun by Daniel Dae Kim) was one of the major players in the 1990 Asian American actors protest of Caucasian actor Jonathan Price playing an Eurasian man in the musical Miss Saigon and how that brouhaha lead to him writing his play Face Value, which was a flop, closing before it opened on Broadway. What isn’t as well known is that the actor cast as the Asian lead in the Boston try-out of Face Value was a white man named Marcus G. Dahlman (Ryan Eggold, in full clueless mode), which would be quite the egg on DHH’s face if it comes to light.